Method Scoring: An Interview with Clint Mansell
Nicholas Britell’s scores are so finely calibrated to the movies they inhabit that they become inextricable from the images on-screen. Whether it’s the staccato heartbeat of orchestral strings in Barry Jenkins’s Moonlight or the mix of piano motifs and hip-hop beats in the TV drama Succession, the sounds that the thirty-eight-year-old composer creates open up a wide range of emotional landscapes while also consistently avoiding the clichés of traditional film music.
A classically trained pianist with a background in hip-hop, Britell has caught the attention of Hollywood with his unique sonic textures, swiftly becoming one of the most sought-after composers in film and television. Central to Britell’s process is the organic rapport he develops with directors, which begins in the earliest stages of production. While he’s worked with a number of different filmmakers, he is best known for his Oscar-nominated collaborations with Jenkins and for his work with Adam McKay, for whom he has scored The Big Short, Vice, and Succession.
Just before netting his first Emmy nomination (for Succession), Britell took some time to chat with me over the phone about his process and his genre-defying sound.
It’s difficult for me to even think about Barry Jenkins’s films without also hearing your music. Your work is so entwined with the emotional fabric of those stories.
I believe there are an infinite number of possible scores anyone could write for a movie, but there’s a subset of those scores that feel like they’re woven into the fabric. There’s something about certain music that just feels like it’s inside the movie when you put it against the picture. Then there’s some music that feels like it’s sitting on top of the movie and has nothing to do with it. And sometimes this difference can be incredibly subtle. The music could be completely right, but if the instrumentation is not right, then it’s wrong—“wrong” in the sense that it doesn’t feel connected to the project.
I love the very deep, close collaborations I’m able to have with directors, and what we do is go on a search together for this feeling. I like getting involved very early on, reading the script and having conversations with the director. Barry often has amazing initial instincts and ideas. For If Beale Street Could Talk, the first thing he said to me was that he imagined the sound of brass and horns. The nice thing about having those early conversations is that some of the ideas turn out to be totally on target, but we also don’t take them as rules. We view everything as starting points and then we go on this journey together.
Are there chords or instruments that you automatically associate with certain emotions?
When I was growing up, I used to spend a lot of time theorizing about this: are there certain chords that feel a certain way? Is there was a lexicon of harmony? But what I’ve discovered is that I don’t think there is. Music has its own internal language, but the way we associate those sounds with feelings, especially in film music, is so determined by what we see.
Let’s say that we’re trying to create a moment that feels sad. You can imagine that you’d use a piece written in a minor key—you could put that against the picture, and it might work. But if you put a piece of music that’s potentially happy over that same sequence, you may find it’s absolutely tragic. Instead of feeling happy, it actually feels like the loss of happiness. Until you put something up against the picture, you have no idea what it’s going to do.
What moods are you drawn to?
When I’m writing I find myself going in certain directions. But I consciously try to not go in a direction where I feel comfortable, because sometimes when you wind up in the same places there’s no friction. I’m not always sitting at a piano when I’m writing, but if I am, I’ll try to play in keys that aren’t comfortable. For many musicians there are the first keys you learn when you start playing, like C major or A minor. Instead of those, I like to play something like F sharp minor or D flat major. There’s a weird link between your hands and your brain, obviously, and when you enter areas that aren’t as familiar, sometimes you wind up in places you didn’t expect.
You mention not always being at the piano—where are you then? Is there a specific environment or routine that helps your process along?
I have a studio in New York that I built in my apartment, and I’ve created it to be very conducive to my musical exploration. I have my computer and my keyboard and multiple screens where I watch the films. One interesting thing I found when I first started working a lot on films was that I wrote different music when I had a small screen versus when I had a big one in front of me. I used to have a separate computer monitor that was about thirty inches, and I would work on a different monitor for the music. But now I have this big flat panel TV that I put on the wall, and I really believe I write differently because of it. I’m much better able to intuit things with the bigger screen; it’s like having a stronger microscope. It also re-creates the immersive theatrical experience better.
My process is very simple. I have a couch and a desk, and I just like looking out the window. I’m alone a lot. I think many composers can have these little hermetic tendencies. But also I often work with my wife, Caitlin [Sullivan], who was the cellist on Beale Street, and she performs very often, so it’s nice to spend time with her and the wonderful community of musicians in New York.
I’m curious about the difference between scoring for the point of view of individual characters and scoring for a larger omniscient narrative arc.
On Moonlight,the emotional point of view that Barry and I explored was through the character Little’s eyes. Barry created this work of poetry, so I was trying to capture a musical idea that echoed that. A film like Vice is such a different emotional world, and yet the task is still the same. It’s the story of the last sixty years in American history, so what we explored was the idea of a dissonant symphony. Adam wanted the music to feel epic in scope, so for me it was about taking what you might expect an American symphony to sound like—brass fanfare—and inserting all these notes that are kind of wrong. Every single piece in the movie is filled with these notes that are technically not part of the scale. What’s interesting is that when you watch the movie you actually get used to all these wrong notes.
In the work of this New York–based filmmaking duo, the internet is an omnipresent force in everyday life, warping our perceptions and desires.
Beloved for her stylistic range and her vibrant portraits of New York City, the director discusses the feminist spirit that runs throughout her work and the collaborations that bring her films to life.
The award-winning actor talks about training with Lee Strasberg, her involvement in the Actors Studio, and her on- and off-screen contributions to two of her most important films.
Writer-archivist-filmmaker Jenni Olson and critic Caden Mark Gardner discuss Masc, a collection of films on the Criterion Channel that explores the many forms of masculinity beyond the realm of cisgender men.
You have no items in your shopping cart