• One Scene: The Human Condition

    By Emma Ríos

    When I first heard about The Human Condition (1959–61), I was already familiar with director Masaki Kobayashi’s irreverent Harakiri (1962), a favorite film of mine where samurai are scum of the earth and honor is equivalent to dirt. I immediately started wondering what a director like him could do with the “modern war” concept for nine hours.

    Hating war and despising any image of glory around it, I admit I’m not a huge fan of the genre. So even though I can foster some affection for classics like 1977’s Cross of Iron, I prefer skewed visions like Hell in the Pacific (1968) or Joyeux Noël (2005), where the human scale is emphasized.

    And that’s the core of The Human Condition: our nature and responsibility to each other. The main character, Kaji, a solitary hero set against the system, is a regular person and a rational coward, just stubborn enough to draw breath every day and stand by his principles. He confronts misfortune and abuse with his idealism, the blood in his veins, and a most terrible inner struggle: an uneasy conscience about being worthy of his own idea of humanism. From his initial innocence to his hard-won survival, through acts of retribution and finally to running away from the beast inside himself, he discovers that the pursuit of acceptance as an individual is one’s purpose in life.

    That journey inspired my illustration. The beautiful cinematography and meaningful dialogue etched a number of key moments into my memory. The crushing disenchantment conveyed by Parts 1 and 2, after Kaji mistakenly thinks he can change the world, not realizing it was ruined from the start, is summed up when he receives this lesson from an elder Chinese prisoner of war: “You’ll either be revealed as a murderer wearing the mask of humanism or as one worthy of the beautiful name . . . man.” Parts 3 and 4 are all about endurance, within an uncaring military and a despicable war, and that theme is especially resonant through Michiko, Kaji’s true love, a beautiful character who is tough and tormented despite her silence.

    But the most shattering and painful segments to watch are Parts 5 and 6, and that pain is often brought about by misunderstandings, across cultures and ideologies. One of my favorite scenes in the whole series is when Kaji, now a prisoner of war himself, is questioned by a Russian officer about his wartime actions, with a portrait of Stalin looming in the background. He tries to explain himself, but a Japanese interpreter, who’s the worst scum of all, has purposefully undermined Kaji throughout the film by giving incorrect translations so the Russians never learn his true thoughts, and vice versa. It’s his sole chance at redemption, and it becomes an unbearable loss of hope. Kaji’s dialogue here sums up the drama perfectly: “The fact that socialism is better than fascism is not enough to keep us alive!”

    Thoughts and words won’t save us. Nothing can save us from ourselves anymore.

    For me, there are too many reasons for drawing a love letter to this movie, but probably the most important one is because I believe watching it can lead us to make better people of ourselves.

    At least it will make you feel like a better person for nine hours.

    Emma Ríos is a comic book creator based in A Coruña, Spain. A former architect, she has been working full-time on comics for nearly six years, first at Boom! Studios, then at Marvel Comics, and now at Image Comics. Her most recent book is Pretty Deadly, a supernatural western on which she collaborated with Kelly Sue DeConnick. She is currently working on a second arc of that story and collaborating with artist Hwei Lim on a sci-fi miniseries called 8House:Mirror, which will be released later this year.

10 comments

  • By Barry Moore
    June 03, 2014
    06:31 PM

    I have yet to catch up with this important work, but it bears repeating that the late historian David Shipman considered this trilogy to collectively be the single greatest achievement in cinema.
    Reply
    • Or using your Criterion.com account.

      You are logged in to your Criterion.com account as . Log out.

    • By Tim
      June 27, 2014
      09:44 PM

      I have seen it (all 9+ hours of it) and I wouldn't disagree with that statement.
  • By Tess Watson
    June 03, 2014
    09:07 PM

    I read this review a while back and really enjoyed it, thought you might too? http://www.worldtransformation.com/an-allegory-for-our-condition/
    Reply
    • Or using your Criterion.com account.

      You are logged in to your Criterion.com account as . Log out.

    • By Barry Moore
      June 04, 2014
      10:08 AM

      Thank you for providing the URL for that indeed interesting article. I have read that the original Japanese title of Kobayashi's opus has the connotation of "the condition that is necessary to be human" rather than "the condition in which human beings find themselves." Not knowing Japanese myself, I cannot vouch for the accuracy of this assertion, but it seems congruent with Kaji's struggle to maintain his idealism and humanity in the most trying of circumstances. I look forward to the time when I may directly experience this film trilogy for myself. Incidentally, the last installment of the trilogy was not released until 1961, though the first was released in 1959 (I am unsure if production extended over those two or so years).
  • By Isak Isakov
    June 04, 2014
    01:27 PM

    This movie is in my top 5 list of all times. I watched the full trilogy two years ago in one day, spent the entire ten hours focusing on it. The ending had devastating effect, though - I couldn't clear out my head for days. The power of this one is absolute and in my mind it is the greatest war (or anti-war some might say) film ever made.
    Reply
  • By Jimmy Melnarik
    June 04, 2014
    01:37 PM

    What a stunning drawing. I would hang that on my wall. The Human Condition is an all-time favorite.
    Reply
  • By Brown
    June 04, 2014
    01:44 PM

    Beautiful art above as well as your work on Pretty Deadly.
    Reply
  • By Brown
    June 04, 2014
    01:46 PM

    Beautiful art above as well as your work on Pretty Deadly.
    Reply
  • By Dean
    June 04, 2014
    02:21 PM

    This is easily on of my all time favorite movies. I personally loved the ending and hope to be able to find more movies of this caliber.
    Reply
  • By MEvers
    June 04, 2014
    06:09 PM

    Please do a print of this art.
    Reply

Or using your Criterion.com account.

You are logged in to your Criterion.com account as . Log out.