During this period, music-video directors transitioning from MTV to features found themselves in the youth ghetto, as producers came to rely on them for their teen-friendly sensibilities. Guncrazy (1992), the debut of Tamra Davis, is a cruel story of youth starring sixteen-year-old Drew Barrymore as a wild child who is dismissed as white trash and goes on a murder spree with her older prison pen pal (James LeGros), the only man who has ever been nice to her. The movie most resembles a music video in that it’s a star text: Barrymore has the bobbed platinum hair and dark eyebrows of early-nineties Madonna, and the film’s iconography builds off Barrymore’s established persona as a teen-tabloid fixture who grew up too fast. She’s a girl with a gun, posing with sidearm, white tank top, and cutoff jeans, her real tattoos plainly visible years before nice girls had any. (The film in turn predicted the appearance of another underage nepo sexpot, Liv Tyler, in the music video for Aerosmith’s “Crazy.”)
Barrymore comes off as a real-life, emotional teenager, with a child’s gestural vocabulary of pouts and giggles and grins. She’s flirty, lush, and too innocent to quite understand how deeply she’s been wronged by the world. Several of Barrymore’s jailbait-era vehicles were directed by women—Katt Shea (Poison Ivy), Antonia Bird (Mad Love)—and like them, Davis seems to really feel for her star, despite building an exploitation film around her libidinous and experimental energy.
Davis offers an exaggerated neorealist vision of the wrong side of the tracks—the trailer park, the abandoned warehouses on the edge of town, and the cars up on blocks in a field where kids shoot at bottles all have a curated dereliction out of Larry Clark’s still photography. Intercutting music performances with outdoor photography, generally in unpromising postindustrial locations, was very common in music videos of the nineties, and Davis herself had followed this template in her videos for the Indigo Girls’ “Closer to Fine,” Tone Loc’s “Wild Thing,” and Hanson’s “MMMBop.” Yet, as indicated by Guncrazy’s titular echo of Joseph H. Lewis, the film is also informed by Hollywood genre cinema, and is thematically and visually in line with open-air run-and-gun American New Wave classics like Bonnie and Clyde and Badlands.
Hollywood recruited music-video directors in hopes of catching some of their novelty and vitality, qualities that—as the failed crossovers of some erstwhile MTV hotshots demonstrate—were sometimes more properly attributed to the music itself. But the opening-credit sequence of Belly, the sole feature by Hype Williams, is the closest cinema has ever come to finding a visual analogue for the galvanic energy of nineties hip-hop culture—a culture in which Williams was a seminal figure and an energy he helped create. The director scored the sequence (which lasts exactly three minutes) with Soul II Soul; shot it at the Chelsea nightclub Tunnel, including in its unisex bathrooms; and populated it with video tropes: dancers, drugs, guns, money. He had experimented with the distorted and coordinated color palettes of nightclub lighting in his videos for “No Diggity” and “Big Poppa,” but the Belly opening is intensified by strobes that limit visibility, as well as a radically restricted palette created by blacklights that turn faces blue and eyes a sharky white—a bioluminescent glow that scrambles skin tones and therefore disrupts racial as well as aesthetic hierarchies (in addition to simply looking unbelievably cool).
Spiraling outward from the opening robbery, Belly is a crime story with a Mean Streets dynamic, riffing on the personae of its central duo, the socially conscious Nas and the mighty DMX. In A Hard Day’s Night, Richard Lester—recipient of a Video Vanguard Award at the first MTV Video Music Awards, in 1984—used quick cuts to evoke the euphoric rush of sixties youth swept up in a movement. In contrast, Belly’s rhythms are slower, woozier, as if each scene is something playing on a TV in the background of a party. Slow motion, low angles, and fisheye lenses make faces and objects bigger than life. Williams’s aesthetic is both triumphal and solemn, apt for a film that follows gangsta rap’s homilies about the rush and temptation of materialism.
Although the rap video was MTV’s leading cultural contribution to the nineties—paving the way for hip-hop’s absorption into mainstream pop, and streetwear’s trickle up into bourgeois fashion—there was at the same time an emerging auteurist music-video canon associated with millennial indie culture. Beginning in 2003, the distributor Palm Pictures released its Directors Label DVDs compiling the work of some of the format’s pioneers. Among the first subjects in the series were Spike Jonze and Michel Gondry, both of whom broke into feature filmmaking by pairing up with screenwriter Charlie Kaufman, whose associative leaps and contorted long-form metaphors required directors who could make digressions feel organic rather than merely quirky.