My Favorite Criterion Films of All Time

by Craig J. Clark

Created 07/11/12

Edit List

I should note that I've culled this list from the Criterion titles in my personal collection. And it could easily be twice as long, or three times as long, or five times as long... You get the idea.

  • Not just my favorite Criterion film, but my favorite film, period. Gilliam creates a world no sane man would want to live in.

  • The only film that comes close to challenging Brazil for the title. I still hold out hope that Soderbergh has a Son of Schizopolis in him before he retires.

  • An amazing film, an amazing score, all wrapped up in the most gorgeous package imaginable.

  • Buñuel at his best. My first exposure to this film was through the Modern Film Scripts series, which was more than enough to entice me into its world.

  • I agree with Marlene Dietrich. Give me back my beautiful Beast!

  • De Palma at his most duplicitous. The film that showed he had studied the Master well and had a few tricks of his own up his sleeves.

  • Just about any Kurosawa film could go in this slot, but I have to tip my hat to this killer noir.

  • Lang was one of the few directors who made masterpieces in the both silent age and the sound era. M proves that, with his first sound film, he had thoroughly thought through what he could do with it.

  • One of the great rediscoveries. Even if it took 37 years to reach our shores, it was definitely worth the wait.

  • After two and a half years of searching, my new favorite Fassbinder.

  • Bonus! I was so tickled when I found out this film is going to be in the Criterion Collection, I just had to throw it onto the pile.


  • By The Narrator Returns
    July 13, 2012
    12:57 PM

    I'm proud to say that I own nine out of ten of these (and two of them are on my Top 11 list). I really need to pick up World on a Wire.
  • By Manish M.
    August 06, 2012
    03:48 PM

    Belle de jour and Beauty and the Beast are in my top 12. I haven't seen the others, dying to see Brazil and High and Low. great list
    • By Craig J. Clark
      August 07, 2012
      10:34 AM

      High and Low is an amazing film. I got to see it on the big screen during a Kurosawa/Mifune retrospective and it totally blew me away.
  • By Jason Andrews
    August 25, 2012
    10:33 PM

    Brazil and Sisters! Excellent list! Brazil was my first CC;bought for me as a wedding anniversary gift.
    • By Craig J. Clark
      August 26, 2012
      08:14 AM

      I'm pretty sure my first Criterion DVD was either Life of Brian or Time Bandits. With Brazil, I had to save up a bit to get the three-disc set.
  • By endo
    August 28, 2012
    02:40 AM

    Thanks for alerting me to the release of The X From Outer Space. I'll also have to check out the Mishima; for some reason I've stayed away.
  • By thenoah
    March 25, 2013
    08:56 PM

  • By thenoah
    March 25, 2013
    08:56 PM

    brazil is the best criterion
    • By Craig J. Clark
      March 28, 2013
      05:48 PM

      I agree. I just shelled out for the Blu-ray, even though I already had the 3-disc DVD release. So worth it.
    July 13, 2013
    12:38 PM

    Love your list!
    • By Craig J. Clark
      July 13, 2013
      09:34 PM

      Thanks. I'm rather fond of it myself.
  • By ScorpioVelvet
    October 20, 2015
    05:45 PM

    Incredible top 10 list, I like your picks (including Brazil and Sisters).